Morgan Stanley pays high cost for funding
Morgan Stanley pays high cost for funding
By Dan Wilchins
NEW YORK, Dec 19 (Reuters) - Morgan Stanley managed to secure funding from a deep pocketed sovereign fund at a rate comparable to what Citigroup is paying in a similar deal, but the price is still high, analysts and convertible bond experts said.
The investment bank said on Wednesday that it was selling up to 9.9 percent of itself to China’s foreign exchange fund for about $5 billion, using securities known as mandatory convertibles. Those securities pay 9 percent a year to the investors until they convert to shares in August 2010.
That 9 percent a year translates to about $450 million of cash out the door next year, equal to about 18 percent of this fiscal year’s earnings.
It also means that in about 2-1/2 years, Morgan Stanley will have to issue a large chunk of new stock, diluting current shareholders.
Investors cheered the move, in part because the new capital will shore up Morgan Stanley’s balance sheet. The company’s shares rose 4.2 percent on Wednesday, after the investment bank said it wrote down $9.4 billion, an amount equal to about a quarter of its third-quarter equity of $35 billion.
“It’s a strange world we live in where dilutive capital raising is considered a positive by the market,” said James Ellman, portfolio manager at hedge fund Seacliff Capital.
In August 2010, the $5 billion face value of the securities will buy Morgan Stanley shares at a 20 percent premium to a reference level, which is expected to be some variation on Morgan Stanley’s share price this week.
When all factors are considered, Morgan Stanley is paying about what Citigroup is paying for its recent $7.5 billion financing from the Gulf Arab emirate of Abu Dhabi. Citi also faces big write-downs.
The 9 percent rate Morgan Stanley is paying looks much lower than the 11 percent Citi is paying to Abu Dhabi.
Some convertible bond experts said Morgan Stanley should be paying even less, given that if Morgan Stanley were to issue new shares, it would have to pay a dividend yield of about 2.2 percent, compared with a 7.1 percent dividend yield for Citigroup.
That would suggest that Morgan Stanley should be paying a rate about 5 percentage points less than Citi on its securities.
But Morgan Stanley’s securities convert to shares sooner than Citi’s, and at a higher premium to current share price, so in the end, their pricing is essentially comparable, a convertible investor said.
(Reporting by Dan Wilchins, editing by Richard Chang)
((Reuters Messaging: dan.wilchins.reuters.com@reuters.net; +1 646 223 6320)) Keywords: MORGANSTANLEY/VALUATION
(C) Reuters 2007. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution ofReuters content, including by caching, framing or similar means, is expresslyprohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters. Reuters and the Reuterssphere logo are registered trademarks and trademarks of the Reuters group ofcompanies around the world.nN19639537
© Reuters 2007 All rights reserved
http://www.reuters.com/article/bankingfinancial-SP-A/idUSN1963953720071221?sp=true